After the gold rush: the weird world of transfer announcements
Over the past decade Scottish football clubs have turned tongue-in-cheek transfer announcements into an artform and a cottage industry. But has it all gone too far?
On a Monday morning in February this year, Kilmarnock’s internal media team were up against the clock.
Aaron Tshibola, a journeyman returning for his fourth stint at Rugby Park, was due to arrive around 8:30 in the morning and meet his teammates at 9:30. That left multimedia executive Scott Symington and social media executive Blair Gormal with a brief window to get everything done before publicly announcing Tshibola’s signing at 10am. Once upon a time in Scottish football, “everything” would have meant an interview and the obligatory scarf-over-the-head shot taken at pitchside. But times have changed, and Symington and Gormal were determined to get Tshibola to do something he’s almost definitely never done at any of the other 12 professional clubs he’s played for: Act.
“It was a very tight turnaround, it was very much a case of: ‘How you doing, nice to meet you, sit there, camera here, say this,’” recalls Symington. “And in like a minute it was done.”
Acting opposite Killie’s new No. 36, thanks to the wonders of modern editing, was Keegan-Michael Key from the American sketch show Key & Peele, and the announcement video the club subsequently released – a gloriously silly recreation of a sketch about an uptight high-school teacher who can’t pronounce the name Aaron – went down a storm: viewed over 100,000 times on X and showered with all the usual praise about giving the admin a raise and winning the internet for today. The otherwise humdrum occurrence of a team sat 11th in the league signing a 31-year-old defensive midfielder on a free had somehow been transformed, however briefly, into a social media event.
“To get it all done and out for 10 o’clock, that was some effort, but ones like that are probably the most fun,” says Gormal.
Perhaps it wouldn’t be the wisest use of a TARDIS, but it’s funny to think how a Kilmarnock fan from the ’80s, ’90s or even early 2000s would react if you went back and showed them that video. Most of us over the age of 30 can still remember a time when transfer announcements were a route-one affair: press conference, photos, a few mumbled lines for the paper or local radio station, and up the road. The only knockabout fun came in the form of tongue-in-cheek photo shoots riffing off the player’s nationality, like those infamous Sheffield Wednesday ones where Paolo Di Canio and Benito Carbone were force-fed dry pasta and an uncooked pizza hurriedly procured from ASDA’s deli counter. Even if you were glued to the back pages of tabloids and a devout Ceefax ultra (page 338; if you know, you know), it wasn’t uncommon for hours to pass before you found out your club had actually signed someone.
For younger readers this will inevitably sound like a Grampa Simpson anecdote, but I can vividly remember following every twist and turn of Harry Kewell’s move from Leeds United to Liverpool on a family holiday in Crete in 2003. I got my updates via imported copies of The Mirror that were already days out of date, but they might as well have been the Dead Sea Scrolls. I didn’t support either club or particularly care about the saga’s outcome, it was just the novelty of being able to access such precious information thousands of miles from home.
Nowadays, of course, in the era of the attention span crisis, the information alone that Player X has signed for Club Y is no longer enough to thrill; it requires bells and whistles. It’s hard to pinpoint precisely when the phenomenon of the transfer announcement video really exploded, but it was probably when the growing cult of the transfer window collided with the rise of social media, around about the time Jim White (interviewed elsewhere in this issue) donned his famous yellow tie for the first time. And as the trend truly took off and spread around the world, Scottish football was firmly established in the vanguard. Where it excelled was in turning its potential weaknesses into virtues.
Whilst the top English clubs’ reveals were often over-produced and over-complicated, the announcements their Scottish counterparts were churning out were defiantly low-budget and low-brow. Nothing captured that contrast better than Manchester United’s rather pompous unveiling of Alexis Sanchez in 2018, featuring the Chilean superstar tinkling away on a grand piano, and the outstanding parody Motherwell put out shortly afterwards to announce Peter Hartley’s contract extension, wherein the English defender played bum notes on a dinky child-sized piano before giving up and smashing it to pieces.
“That was the perfect Scottish response to the over-inflated self-importance of the English game,” Ian Fitzpatrick, a football marketing consultant who has worked with Stenhousemuir and Clyde, tells Nutmeg. “It said, ‘We see what you’re doing, and we’re going to do it for 50 quid and a laugh.’ Their timing was spot-on and they got a load of good press from big clubs off the back of it.”
What happened over the next couple of years felt a little like a gold rush, as Scottish clubs big and small suddenly realised all they needed was a camera, a concept and a player or manager willing to enter into the spirit of it, and they could potentially go viral around the world. Everyone will have their personal favourites, but Partick Thistle’s effort from 2021, when they smash-cut the music video for Breakfast at Tiffany’s by Deep Blue Something together with Ian McCall deadpanning, “We’ve signed Scott Tiffoney… ya beauty!”, warrants special mention.
Five years down the line, however, the climate seems to have changed. Some clubs are rationing their wackier video ideas. Others seem to have knocked it on the head entirely. And more broadly, there is a growing sense that the whole thing might just have jumped the shark somewhere along the way. A sense that there’s only a finite amount of usable Still Game and Chewin’ the Fat clips left down in the content mines, and that the day might soon come when Scottish football fans turn to their clubs en masse and say the immortal words: “You’ve took that too far.”
A Nutmeg contributor and former head of digital at the SFA, Michael Bochel serves on the committee of his hometown team Nairn County, where a Highland League budget dictates that transfer announcements are kept simple and straight to the point. As it happens, though, that’s the approach Bochel expects most Scottish Premiership clubs to adopt in the coming years.
“I believe we’ve reached a point where club media teams feel the time and resource investment versus the return is no longer worth it,” he observes. “The novelty has worn off, and it now takes something genuinely special to capture attention. In a world where X – where these videos used to gain the most traction – is no longer what it once was, and where clubs have become more strategic with their social media and messaging, I don’t think creating something wacky is high on the agenda for many anymore.
“You have to ask first and foremost: who are these videos for? If you’re alienating part of your fanbase by going too niche with the theme, you could argue you’ve wasted a fair amount of time when fans ultimately just want official confirmation of who has been signed.
“But there is still scope to do something topical if you get the production quality right. Rangers, for example, did a Traitors-themed announcement in the January transfer window, which mixed things up a bit.”
Scroll through the social media feeds of Premiership clubs during the last two transfer windows and you’ll find a diverse range of tactics at work. The interesting part is figuring out the motivation behind it. The arch jokers back in 2018, in 2026 Motherwell are instead focused on simple, stylish short clips with high production values, and on maintaining a consistent look and feel for all their announcements during a window, rather than coming up with a new premise for each one. And Hearts’ recent approach is similar. At Fir Park, where the media team has rarely been found behind the curve in recent years, the suspicion is that they’ve simply cottoned on to wider industry trends a bit faster than most of their contemporaries. But could self-image have something to do with the change of tack at Tynecastle? It certainly stands to reason that a Tony Bloom-owned, title-chasing version of Hearts would want to project a more serious, professional air than the version that, as recently as three years ago, was announcing the signing of Costa Rican winger Kenneth Vargas by referencing a Peep Show scene about Mark Corrigan’s sex toy…
The bigger the club, the less appetite for taking creative risks, it seems, but anyone who thinks the big two are above all this frivolity has clearly forgotten that Celtic were chucking Come Dine With Me memes around as recently as the Ange Postecoglou era. The Parkhead outfit’s recent announcements have certainly fallen into the safe and bland category, but that probably says more about not wanting to further provoke a fanbase that are already at war with the board, than it does about a paucity of ideas in the media team.
As for Rangers, they seem to have plotted a course right down the middle of the competing factions, mixing the odd big reference – Star Wars for Andreas Skov Olsen, The Traitors for Ryan Naderi – with more traditional reveals where the emphasis in subsequent posts quickly switches to slick graphics and sharp photography.
But let’s skip to the fun bit. Because if there’s one Scottish club that couldn’t care less about jumping the shark, it’s the one that once dressed up their new striker (Bruce Anderson) as a great white and got him to recite lines from Finding Nemo. At a time when others are toning things down and scaling back, Kilmarnock appear to subscribe to the Limmy philosophy instead: don’t back doon, double doon. In the last year-and-a-half, Killie’s announcements have paid homage to Taylor Swift, Dr Who, The Sopranos and Stranger Things, to name just a few. Won’t somebody think of the humble scarf-over-the-head photo?
“Oh, we do do those!” Gormal insists. “Almost just as patter. Once we’ve done the video and the announcement, I like to chuck a scarf photo in as well, just for the traditionalists.”
Strictly speaking, not all of Kilmarnock’s recent reveals have made sense. The general rule of thumb with transfer announcements is that there has to be some tenuous connection between the thing that you’re referencing and the player’s name, nationality or personality. Killie have torn that particular page out of the rulebook and shredded it, freeing them up to create some of their maddest and most entertaining signing content yet.
“Obviously if a name plays into the context then brilliant, but we don’t let that restrict us,” Symington explains. “If it works as a reveal, is funny to us, and maintains the high quality standard we have set for ourselves, then we just go for it. We feel we have enough credit with our fans and have garnered a reputation to the point where people actively await our next announcement, which alleviates any real feeling of risk, as that reputation means we’ll get away with however ridiculous it is. One of the most ridiculous was turning [Liverpool loanee and Scotland cap] Calvin Ramsay into the dastardly penguin/chicken Feathers McGraw, from Wallace & Gromit. Sometimes ideas come from what’s current and most popular for engagement, but with others we just use personal favourites. Feathers McGraw is one of my favourite movie characters, and quite simply I thought it would be incredibly funny to see a professional football club tweet about him! That video in particular was very much a case of ‘trust the process’, I had to tell the club staff and even Calvin himself, trust me, the end product will be a hit. And thankfully it did prove very popular.”
Kilmarnock’s media team are young and ‘online’ enough to be bursting with ideas, but they’re also locals who support the club, meaning they know when ideas like Feathers McGraw will, ahem, fly, and when they won’t. So, surely this season, in the midst of a tense relegation battle, there has been more temptation than usual to compromise on style and play it straight for once?
“When the January window opened, we weren’t sure this time,” Symington admits. “We actually kind of debated it. But in the end we thought, ‘It’s who we are as a media team.’ So, we just went for it with the first couple of announcements. And the game we had at the weekend [a 3-0 loss at Hibs], that’s probably the most compliments we’ve ever had to our face. It put a positive spin on that transfer window, and it does play a part in the whole narrative of getting the fans back onside and creating a more positive atmosphere around the team.”
“It’s part of Scottish football now, and part of Scottish culture in general,” adds Gormal. “You try and make a joke and have a laugh. We’ve had good feedback from other clubs as well. I was speaking to somebody from Portland Timbers in the MLS, and they’d seen some of our stuff, so it’s interesting that its reach goes that far. It makes you wonder about the bigger [Scottish] clubs, especially when things are going well for them on the pitch – why aren’t they being a bit more creative?”
Tasked with overseeing all the madness and making sure it doesn’t ruffle any feathers (sorry) in the boardroom or stands is Ewan Paton, Kilmarnock’s media & communications manager. Paton only joined the club in the spring, but was watching on with interest in the January window, when his soon-to-be colleagues marked the arrival of highly-rated winger Findlay Curtis on loan from Rangers by depicting him as ‘King Curtis’, a badly behaved seven-year-old with a chicken nugget addiction who featured in an episode of Wife Swap USA. The rule that announcement videos should only reference mainstream films and TV that we’ve all seen is another Killie are happy to flout; the thinking being that, even if the reference sails clean over your head – like it did mine – the clip is edited cleverly enough to still make you smile.
“I was exactly the same, I did not understand what that was,” Paton laughs. “But I spoke to the boys and they’d had it prepared for ages. I was like, ‘I have no clue what you’re talking about, but I’m sure it’ll go down well.’ And it got a big reaction. There’s an element of trust here where they’ll allow us to have that freedom, and they know that we’re not going to do anything to the detriment of the club. Ultimately, speaking for these guys, who have been here and done it for a number of years now, our bosses have been delighted with the progress we’ve made in that regard, and they’re encouraging of us trying to think outside the box.”
So, what approach is better: Kilmarnock’s maximalism, or the minimalism in evidence at clubs like Motherwell? Rather than arranging an Anchorman-style gang fight between the media teams, we thought we’d just ask Ian Fitzpatrick.
“You’re looking at two clubs that embody the ‘brand vs buzz’ debate, and I’m all for it! My preference is the Motherwell approach, but I’m biased in that I come from a corporate world where branding and professionalism are all-important. However, if I was advising a club tomorrow, I’d be telling them to lean towards the Killie model, but with Motherwell’s polish. In Scottish football, our biggest asset is our personality; we will never outspend the English Premier League, but we can out-entertain them. My advice with everything like this though is to know your audience and fans. Keep an eye on what they respond to and what they don’t, and that will be your best indicator of which route to take.”
Killie might be an outlier in the Premiership, but in the wild west of content that is the lower leagues, it’s a different story. Young media pros are producing some remarkable work in tiers two, three, four and even below, defying the limitations imposed on them by minimal resources, dodgy wi-fi connections and part-time players that are hardly ever around to star in your latest production. Callum Rattray was formerly head of media at Caledonian Braves – the Lowland League side renowned for punching above their weight in media terms – and recently became the new digital media executive at the club he grew up supporting, Raith Rovers.
“Scottish football is absolutely packed with talented content creators, you have to be impressed by the work of employees and volunteers alike at clubs up and down the SPFL,” he says. “Production value has really improved, and some clubs create content that is visually incredible, which is very important now. When I worked in the Lowland League, I would often come across one-man-band media teams, which really provides some perspective on the challenges some people face. The more people talking about Scottish football – especially outside of the Old Firm – the better, so there’s nothing better than going to the pub and the topic of conversation is Raith Rovers due to a post-match cartoon. And, love it or hate it, but a big shoutout to my good friend Aaron Fraser at Edinburgh City – how many more people have spoken about City this season due to his videos of the team singing Wagon Wheel after a win?!”
Pound for pound Raith might be the best club in the country to work for, if you like taking creative risks and rocking the boat.
“Communication is key here, and I’m lucky to have great support from top to bottom when it comes to these decisions,” Rattray, who also co-hosts the Joga Bonito podcast, adds. “[Director] Ruaridh Kilgour has clearly been good at implementing this content since he joined the club, so plenty of credit to him. When it comes to risky content ideas, timing is key, and if you wait too long, you can miss the opportunity.”
It may not get quite as much attention as it did two years ago when they were vying for Premiership promotion, but the Rovers are still pumping out plenty of provocative, attention-grabbing content, from those infamous cartoons to signing announcements like the one Callum got to work on shortly after taking up his new role, depicting loan arrival Innes Cameron as ‘Big Innes’, the Midori-swilling hard man from Still Game. In a way, it was an open goal; Cameron is 6’3” and had already been saddled with the nickname in his time at Kilmarnock (surprise-surprise), but Raith still executed it with panache, then built on it in the weeks that followed, as Cameron’s brace in the Challenge Cup final victory over Inverness cemented him as a Stark’s Park cult hero.
“That’s one I helped come up with and edited, and really that was given to us on a silver platter. But one thing you don’t want to do after an announcement is to go onto social media and see loads of supporters responding with something better than your own announcement, which almost certainly would’ve happened in this instance. Overall, Still Game isn’t one I’d rush back to, as we always look to be different where we can, but it’s all just a bit of fun at the end of the day.”
Does it go to show that there’s still life in the old dog yet when it comes to Still Game-themed transfer reveals, and that that’s not “plenty” after all?
“I don’t think that we have taken it too far yet, but we’re close to it,” Fitzpatrick reflects. “My rule for Still Game references would be: if you have to explain the joke to a non-fan, don’t do it. If it feels organic to the player’s personality, it’s a winner. If you’re just shoehorning a ‘Shut up, Shug’ clip into a generic signing, it’s time to move on. Unfortunately, some clubs are desperate to go viral, and when it doesn’t work, it just becomes cringy.”
Where all of this stuff is headed is anyone’s guess, but the genie isn’t going back in the bottle any time soon. Strikingly, Partick Thistle recently took pelters from fans on X, not because of the content of their signing announcements, but because they hadn’t teased them beforehand. Not so much as a humble pen emoji. The modern-day fan doesn’t necessarily insist on a video reveal with an elaborate concept, but they do seem to need something that creates a sense of occasion and reflects their own level of excitement back at them.
Around the time this issue reaches you, the summer transfer window will re-open, and we’ll get a clearer indication on whether it’s the serious announcements or the silly ones that are holding sway down in Scottish football’s content mines. For now, all we can say for sure is that anyone thinking of signing for Kilmarnock better be ready to dress up and act their heart out.
“A lot of the time they know what’s coming,” Gormal laughs. “They just know they’re gonna end up in a costume or something. We’ve not really thought of anything for the summer so far, but between now and then the world as a whole could be a completely different place.”
“Our job actually changes the experience of watching movies and TV shows,” Symington concludes. “Always in the back of my mind I’m thinking, ‘Would this work? How could we turn this into an announcement?’ Sometimes we feel the pressure if we start a transfer window with a strong one, it’s like, ‘Oh, eyes are on us now!’ But I like that, it makes you want to keep it up. What’s the long-term strategy? Just vibes!”
Published in Issue 40
June 2026
Discover Issue 40Scott Fleming is a subtitler and football writer originally from Glasgow but now working for Liverpool FC on Merseyside. He has a particular interest in the strange bedfellows that are Italian Serie A and Scottish Junior football.