Nutmeg Magazine Nutmeg Magazine
Subscribe

I’m sure we can all recall the childhood clamour for playground captaincy and the prestige which came with “picking sides” – but what’s captaincy like at professional level? Does the reality of life as the skipper live up to our boyish fantasies or is it an altogether more serious proposition? Let’s delve deeper into the men behind the armband, the managers that put them there and the associated perks and challenges which come with the privilege.

As a young, sport-obsessed lad growing up in the early 2000s, I was all too familiar with the pre-eminent captains of the day. Many, I believe, were what James Gandolfini in his iconic role as Tony Soprano would class as “the strong silent type”. Warriors who led from the front, refusing to yield even the tiniest of inches – think Steve Waugh relentlessly flogging England, Roy Keane staring down Patrick Vieira or Andy Farrell single-handedly fighting off three or four St Helens players and you’ll soon get the picture. These granite-chiselled icons were men of a different era, a time when career-ending challenges, twenty-over spells and 26-man punch-ups were de rigeur. They inspired and intimidated in equal measure, leaving behind a legacy of both triumph and respect.

As I progressed through childhood to adolescence, athletes such as these became the benchmark. All had ability in abundance, an unmistakable presence on the pitch and a will to win that verged on the obsessive – admirable characteristics for any young sporting hopeful to aspire to. I was trusted with the armband from a pretty young age, rotating bowlers when donning the whites, or encouraging teammates on mud-strewn pitches. There’s an element of thinking that goes into marshalling a bowling attack that differs from the cut-and-thrust nature of a football game. Even at junior level, an astute change from pace to spin could hugely impact a game, whereas football called for a more direct form of intervention – a big tackle, a match-winning strike or a goal-line clearance.

Having been signed by Manchester United at the tender age of eight-years-old, I’d already experienced captaincy at both school and local level and as my sporting development continued to progress, I’d go on to lead out my small Lancastrian district with the bat and ball. With a distinctly average bowling action and slightly above-par batting ability, any hopes of following in the footsteps of Red Rose icons like Stuart Law or James Anderson were highly unlikely to be realised, but the experiences gained in leadership served me well, further down the line.

Upon leaving secondary school, I joined up with Manchester United, where I was thrust into a world that few experience. The squad featured world-class players such as Paul Scholes, Wayne Rooney and Dimitar Berbatov. United had just lifted their 19th first division title and were on the hunt for the all-consuming, Liverpool-eclipsing, No.20. Serbian legend, Nemanja Vidic was charged with leading this star-studded squad in its pursuit of greatness. His on-field style was general-like, a Slavic bulwark at the heart of United’s defence, whilst his off-field demeanour was altogether more regal – impeccable posture, a friendly smile and the respect of his peers the order of the day.

A GOOD CAPTAIN HAS THE ABILITY TO BE RESPECTED BY HIS PEERS, BE HONEST WITH HIS MANAGER AND DRIVE STANDARDS ON THE FIELD OF PLAY. I GENUINELY BELIEVE THAT IF THE RIGHT CHARACTER IS CHOSEN, THEY CAN VASTLY INCREASE THE CHANCES OF SUCCESS.

For a vast part of my first full-time year, I was forced to take a watching brief, consigned to the gym with a stress-fractured back. Throughout the long, gruelling months of treatment and conditioning, I was lucky enough to observe legends of the game going about their business. Ryan Giggs, by this stage approaching his 40th year, was fastidious in his efforts to avoid injury, whilst Michael Owen was grafting hard to overcome his own injury-plagued campaign. I managed to return to the field at the back end of the season, slowly regaining confidence and nailing down a place in the Under-18 team.

At the beginning of the following season, the youth team manager, Paul McGuiness, chose me as the team foreman – which bestowed upon me a greater responsibility away from the pitch. As young upstarts, we each had our role to play in ensuring that the Carrington training ground was kept in decent order. We’d each be divided into teams and would go about our jobs at the beginning and end of each day. One group would pump up the balls for training (woe betide those who put too much air in the first team bag) and another would prepare the drinks hamper, whilst the cleaning of the physio room and the enormous gym were also important jobs on the rota. It was my job to ensure that all of the above were completed in a timely and efficient manner. Sir Alex Ferguson’s Manchester United hadn’t dominated two decades of English football by accepting poor standards.

On the field I was also trusted with the captaincy. This was a real privilege for a small-town boy at one of the world’s greatest footballing institutions. The group was made up of northern lads who I’d played with since I was eight, a smattering of talented youth from elsewhere in the British Isles and a sprinkling of star talent from other European countries. The continental contingent included my good friend and future Scudetto champion Pierluigi Gollini, jinky Scandinavian dribbler Mats Moller Daehli and the supremely gifted Adnan Januzaj. To lead a group of highly-talented young men was certainly not without its issues (egos, jealousy and expectation weighed heavy), but I steadily grew into the role and gained in confidence as the season went on. An agonising FA Youth Cup defeat by Burnley at Old Trafford was a real low point – the entirety of the club’s hierarchy were in attendance for a competition that it regards with the utmost importance.

The end of my two-year scholarship saw me sign my first professional contract. Sat across the desk from Mr Ferguson, my hands sweated as he broke the news. Surrounded by horse racing memorabilia and a collection of hardback books, he informed me that he’d be offering me a two-year deal and wished me well for the coming season. If I was to make the breakthrough, it would have to be under the stewardship of someone other than the Govan-born legend. After lifting a record breaking 20th top division title, Sir Alex had announced his decision to retire from the professional game.

Louis Van Gaal would be the man to take the reins. Whilst training with the first eleven was a regular occurrence, earning a place in a heavily-stacked reserve side was a tough enough proposition. Household names such as Jesse Lingard and the Keane brothers were mainstays, while “drop in” appearances from first teamers such as Robin Van Persie, Wilfred Zaha and Ander Herrera were a regular occurrence. I captained the Under-19 squad in the inaugural UEFA Youth Champions League, where we mirrored the fixtures of the senior side. A 4-3, ten-man victory over Bayer Leverkusen was the highlight; an early dismissal in the return leg the opposite.

My Manchester United journey culminated in me taking the armband for the Reserve side – it would be the last time in a 12-year professional career that I would do so. It was never something that bothered or particularly interested me during my playing days, but in retrospect it does seem a bit bizarre that a former Manchester United youth and reserve team captain would be constantly overlooked in any leadership role.

The best captains I played under conducted themselves in a befitting manner both on and off the pitch. Not all were what you’d class as your archetypal captain; some drove their teammates forward with actions, others with encouraging words and none went hiding. A good skipper is worth their weight in gold, whilst the opposite can be said of those less suited to the role.

On many occasions over the years I’ve witnessed managers choose their captain based on the wrong criteria. “Who’s got the biggest ego? I want to keep them on side.” A recipe for disaster.

“Who can disrupt the dressing room? I want to keep them happy.” Weak.

“Who can I trust to report back any dressing room dissent?” Treasonous.

A good captain has the ability to be respected by his peers, be honest with his manager and drive standards on the field of play. I genuinely believe that if the right character is chosen, they can vastly increase the chances of success relative to their particular club, serving as the fulcrum on which fortunes rise and fall. For the most part, for a role that requires such devotion, it can be a thankless task – appearing at a club function when the team is on a losing streak is far more common than lifting a trophy.

Looking back, I feel as though the responsibility of captaincy may have brought out the best in me, one that would have benefited both myself and my employers. A captain can’t afford to coast through a game, the greats are front and centre, in the thick of things during the good times and the bad. In the latter stages of my career this was something that improved markedly in my game. Perhaps the added weight of the armband would have further enhanced my performance, but who’s to know? After all, hindsight is simply the foresight of a gobshite.

Published in Issue 41

September 2026

Discover Issue 41

Liam Grimshaw is a former Motherwell, Morton and Dundee United player

Basket 0

Your basket is currently empty.